Skip to content
Back to home Book an ops audit

Guides · Fulfillment

How to switch 3PLs without losing orders

Switching 3PLs is one of the riskiest weeks a small brand goes through. Done badly, orders sit in limbo, stock shows as available in two places or none, and customers find out before you do. Done well, nobody outside the business notices. Here is how we run the move.

Decide why you're leaving, in writing

Most switches start with frustration: slow shipping, wrong counts, surprise fees. Before you sign with anyone new, write down the three or four problems you need fixed and how you'll measure them. Ship-on-time rate, receiving time, accuracy of counts and the real cost per order are the usual ones. That list becomes your contract checklist and your way to tell, three months later, whether the move was worth it.

Read the new contract for receiving fees, storage minimums, account-management charges and what happens to your stock if you leave. The quote rarely matches the first invoice.

Ask the questions that matter before signing

Ask how they handle receiving when a shipment arrives short or damaged, how quickly they count it in, and who you call when something goes wrong on a Friday afternoon. Ask to see a sample invoice and a sample stock report. Ask other small brands they work with how the first month went. A warehouse that answers these clearly and in writing will usually be easier to work with later.

Plan the inventory move before anything else

The order integration is the easy part. The stock is where money gets lost. Get a full count from the outgoing 3PL and reconcile it against your own records before anything ships. Shrinkage and old discrepancies you never resolved will follow you to the new warehouse if you don't.

Decide whether you'll move everything at once or split stock for a period. A split lets you keep shipping during the transfer, but only if your store knows exactly which warehouse holds what. If you can't route orders by location cleanly, a short, planned pause in shipping is often safer than running two half-stocked warehouses.

Map every place orders come from

Your storefront is one source. Subscription renewals, wholesale orders, replacements sent by support, influencer shipments and anything entered by hand are others. Each one needs a path to the new 3PL, and each one should be tested with a real order before cutover. The orders that go missing are almost always the ones nobody thought to list.

Check SKU mapping line by line. Bundles and kits are a common trap: the store sells one item, the warehouse needs to pick three. If the new 3PL builds kits differently, fix it before go-live, not after the first wave of short shipments.

Pick a cutover moment and stick to it

Choose a quiet day, away from promotions and subscription renewal peaks. Set a clear cutoff: orders before this time ship from the old 3PL, orders after ship from the new one. Tell support what to say if someone asks where their order is, and turn off any automation that might push orders to the old warehouse after the cutoff.

Keep the old 3PL connection live but paused for a few days, so you can see anything that still tries to route there.

Agree how you'll work together

Set up one shared channel with the new 3PL and agree who on each side owns problems. Decide how you'll report damaged items, short picks and address issues, and how fast they should respond. Small habits like a short weekly check-in in the first month save hours of email chasing later and make problems visible before customers feel them.

Watch the first two weeks closely

Look at unfulfilled orders every day, not every week. Compare what the store says is in stock with what the new 3PL reports. Check that tracking numbers are flowing back to customers and that returns have somewhere to go. Expect a few problems. What matters is catching them in days rather than finding them in a month-end report.

Once things are steady, close the old account properly: final stock reconciliation, last invoice, and confirmation that nothing is still connected.

Where we come in

We plan and run 3PL moves for small brands, from contract review to the first clean month. AI helps with the repetitive checks, like matching order and stock reports, but a person makes the calls and talks to the warehouse. If a switch is on your horizon, a free ops audit call is a good place to start.

Want a second pair of eyes on this?

The ops audit is a free 30-minute call. We look at your operations together and you leave with next steps, whether or not you hire us.

Book an ops audit →

P11 · Ecommerce operations, builds & automation · [email protected]

Guides · FAQ · Working with P11 · Privacy Policy · © 2026 P11